Summary
RELATE used predictable logic to generate sign-in keys and exam ticket codes, making it feasible for an attacker to guess or brute-force these tokens.
Under conditions where attackers can target token-based authentication or exam access endpoints, this weakness may allow unauthorized account access, exam impersonation, or bypass of exam integrity controls.
Affected context
This vulnerability occurs in RELATE deployments that rely on application-generated tokens for:
- User sign-in keys produced by
auth.py'smake_sign_in_key() - Exam ticket codes produced by
exam.py'sgen_ticket_code()
The issue arises when these tokens are used as proof of identity or authorization and are generated using patterns that are guessable or insufficiently random.
Exploit preconditions
- Attack surface: Public-facing sign-in mechanisms and exam access endpoints that accept RELATE sign-in keys or exam ticket codes.
- Required access: Network access to the RELATE application (e.g., a student, user, or external attacker who can reach the web interface).
- Trigger point: Submission of crafted or brute-forced sign-in keys or exam ticket codes to the corresponding endpoints.
- Why exploitation is possible: The token generation functions rely on predictable or low-entropy methods, reducing the effective search space and enabling an attacker to guess valid tokens in a practical timeframe.
Why this happens
The core issue maps to CWE-330: Use of Insufficiently Random Values and CWE-338: Use of Cryptographically Weak Pseudo-Random Number Generator (PRNG).
Instead of using a cryptographically secure source of randomness and adequately long token values, the make_sign_in_key() and gen_ticket_code() functions generate values that follow patterns or have limited entropy.
When such tokens are used for authentication or authorization, predictability undermines their security guarantees and allows attackers to bypass normal login or exam access flows by guessing valid tokens.
Potential impact
- Unauthorized use of sign-in keys, potentially leading to account takeover or impersonation.
- Unauthorized access to exams via guessed exam ticket codes.
- Compromise of exam integrity, including viewing or submitting exams as another user.
- Circumvention of access controls that rely on token-based verification.
- Erosion of audit trails and non-repudiation where tokens are treated as identity proof.
General mitigation guidance
Effective mitigation focuses on replacing predictable token generation with robust, cryptographically secure mechanisms and tightening how tokens are used:
- Use cryptographically secure random number generators designed for security-sensitive tokens.
- Increase token length and complexity to expand the search space beyond practical brute-force limits.
- Bind tokens to user identity and context (e.g., user ID, exam ID, and expiration time) and validate those bindings on use.
- Apply strict expiration and single-use semantics for sign-in keys and ticket codes.
- Enforce rate limiting and anomaly detection on endpoints that accept tokens to reduce brute-force feasibility.
- Design authentication and exam access workflows so that loss or prediction of a single token does not fully compromise an account or exam.
How teams detect issues like this
Organizations can detect and guard against predictable token generation through:
- Static analysis and code review:
- Flag use of non-cryptographic randomness APIs (e.g., generic PRNGs or deterministic patterns) in authentication or exam-related code paths.
- Look for short or fixed-format tokens used for sign-in or access control.
- Review custom token generation functions in authentication and exam modules for entropy and predictability concerns.
- Runtime and operational monitoring:
- Monitor for unusual rates of token validation attempts, suggesting brute-force activity.
- Log token generation and validation events (without recording actual token values) to spot patterns or abuse.
- Policy and tooling:
- Enforce secure coding guidelines that require cryptographically secure RNGs for all security-sensitive tokens.
- Integrate automated code scanning tools that include rules for CWE-330 and CWE-338 in CI pipelines.

