/

CVE-2024-51346

Severity:

HIGH RISK

(7.7)

Insufficient Entropy / Weak Randomness in Cryptography

CVE-2024-51346

Awaiting Analysis

Vulnerability type

Category:

Insufficient Entropy / Weak Randomness in Cryptography

CWE:

CWE-330

Impact:

Exposure of Sensitive Information

Severity:

HIGH RISK

(7.7)

CVSS version:

3.1

Catch this CVE while code is being written

Detect vulnerable code directly in pull requests, so CVEs are fixed before merge.

Summary

Eufy Homebase 2 version 3.3.4.1h uses a cryptographic scheme that relies on insufficient or predictable randomness, allowing sensitive information to be derived by an attacker.

A local attacker with access to the device or its communication channel may exploit the weak entropy to recover secrets or decrypt protected data under certain conditions.

Affected context

This vulnerability affects Eufy Homebase 2 devices running firmware version 3.3.4.1h that rely on on-device cryptographic routines for protecting sensitive data such as keys, tokens, or session material.

The issue is present when security assumptions depend on random values (e.g., keys, nonces, initialization vectors, or challenges) that are generated or derived using a scheme that lacks sufficient entropy or is otherwise predictable.

The risk is most pronounced in environments where an attacker can observe or interact with the device locally, monitor its traffic, or repeatedly trigger cryptographic operations.

Exploit preconditions

  • Attack surface: Local to the device environment; may include physical access, access to the local network where the device communicates, or access to locally stored data generated by the cryptographic scheme.
  • Required access: The attacker generally needs local-level access (e.g., proximity to the device's network, access to logs or stored data, or ability to interact with the device's interface or API).
  • Trigger point: Repeated or targeted use of the vulnerable cryptographic scheme, such as generation of keys, session tokens, or encrypted records that rely on weak randomness.
  • Why exploitation is possible: Because the cryptographic scheme uses insufficient or low-quality entropy, the effective key or secret space is reduced, enabling an attacker to predict, brute-force, or derive sensitive values more easily than intended.

Why this happens

The root cause aligns with CWE-330: Use of Insufficiently Random Values.

In cryptographic contexts, random values must be generated using a high-entropy, cryptographically secure source. When a system uses predictable seeds, low-entropy sources (e.g., timestamps, device IDs, or small counters), or non-cryptographic pseudo-random generators for security-critical operations, the resulting values become guessable.

In Eufy Homebase 2, the cryptographic scheme appears to depend on randomness that is not sufficiently unpredictable, undermining confidentiality guarantees and enabling sensitive information to be inferred from observed outputs or limited brute-force search.

Potential impact

  • Disclosure of cryptographic keys, tokens, or other sensitive material derived from weak randomness
  • Decryption of data that is expected to be confidential under normal operation
  • Impersonation of legitimate devices or sessions by predicting or reproducing security tokens
  • Facilitation of further attacks such as replay, session hijacking, or escalation against associated services

General mitigation guidance

Mitigation generally focuses on strengthening the randomness used in all security-sensitive operations and reducing the impact of any single secret's compromise.

Common defensive patterns include:

  • Using cryptographically secure random number generators (CSPRNGs) that are appropriate for the platform and seeded with sufficient entropy
  • Avoiding application-level randomness constructions based on predictable values such as timestamps, MAC addresses, serial numbers, or low-range counters
  • Ensuring that all long-term keys, ephemeral keys, nonces, and challenges are generated using a vetted cryptographic library rather than custom implementations
  • Designing protocols so that compromise of one key or token does not automatically expose other sessions or long-term secrets (e.g., using key rotation and forward secrecy concepts)
  • Minimizing storage of sensitive intermediate values and enforcing least-privilege access to any stored cryptographic material

How teams detect issues like this

Detection strategies typically combine code-level analysis with behavioral review of cryptographic operations:

  • Static analysis: Scan for calls to non-cryptographic random APIs, hard-coded seeds, or manual seeding of PRNGs used in cryptographic contexts.
  • Code review signals: Look for custom randomness implementations, direct use of system time or easily observable device identifiers to generate keys or tokens, and absence of platform-recommended CSPRNGs.
  • Cryptographic design review: Evaluate protocols to ensure that randomness requirements are clearly specified and that all security-critical parameters are generated via cryptographically secure mechanisms.
  • Dynamic analysis: Empirically test output distributions of random values (keys, nonces, tokens) for predictability or low variance when feasible.
  • Automated tooling (SAST, specialized crypto analyzers) can help flag insecure randomness patterns in firmware or application code during development and security assessments.

Sources

SourceLink
github.comgithub.com/victorGoeman/Eufy-Ecosystem-Security-Research/blob/main/CVE-2024-51346.md
github.comgithub.com/victorGoeman/Eufy-Ecosystem-Security-Research/blob/main/README.md
eufy.comeufy.com/

Frequently asked

questions

The description indicates a local attacker, so exploitation generally assumes local or near-local access (e.g., same network, physical access, or access to local data). Purely remote exploitation over the internet is less likely unless other issues expose the weakly protected data or keys.

An attacker typically needs local access to the device environment, its traffic, or its stored data. This could include being on the same LAN, having access to device logs or backups, or physical proximity that allows interaction with the device or its network.

The most robust fix is to replace all security-critical randomness with cryptographically secure random number generation provided by well-vetted libraries, ensuring that keys, nonces, and tokens are derived from high-entropy sources and not from custom or predictable schemes.

Adopt a defensive development process that mandates use of approved cryptographic libraries, includes cryptographic design reviews, and integrates static analysis rules specifically targeting insecure randomness, while avoiding custom randomness logic in security functions.

Find out what's already
exploitable in your codebase.